Energy Resources and Sustainability

2. Batteries and Fuel Cells

Learning outcomes
  • I can describe how fossil fuels and nuclear fuels are used to generate useful energy.
  • I can identify the energy transformations involved in power generation.
  • I can compare the energy densities of different non-renewable energy sources.
  • I can evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of non-renewable energy technologies.
  • I can analyze the environmental impacts associated with non-renewable energy use.

Batteries and Fuel Cells

The title “Batteries and Fuel Cells” does not quite match the learning targets provided. These targets are specifically about fossil fuels, nuclear fuels, non-renewable energy generation, energy density, and environmental impacts.

I’ll follow the learning targets, so these notes are essentially about Non-Renewable Energy Technologies. If “Batteries and Fuel Cells” is the intended topic, those would need a different set of notes and targets.

Non-Renewable Energy Technologies

Non-renewable energy resources are resources that are consumed much faster than natural processes can replace them.

The major non-renewable energy resources are:

  • coal
  • oil
  • natural gas
  • nuclear fuels such as uranium

Fossil fuels store energy chemically, while nuclear fuels store energy within atomic nuclei.

Both can provide enormous quantities of useful energy, but they involve very different physical processes and environmental impacts.

https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/sq-SV7xMPjgslFatEDujY8yhwra5M_wJsQpcyyBy0u6SPTghnR61i8TVlXEsH8msCKBAkFxHcsddoTPwl5HXDz1T0vzxwm-a_2om1YkSLopfrGR4UjBJZXGVEAZ6o7Sk-gEZc-KRlHOhBAI6-eYaFJstbycBatoYOG2qhjEUczzdX0JHnGjbf59ENBbyCrzn?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/9Y70o72qx9yKECyXjxAeQ-1Sg0FnFv2c-drssxMH_9R4uc3bGfWahC46dQlKq00N3LM-GUVnqZR_UaAzor1cPIVukxWEfCOIyD3t9yDIriksqvoql6gHxeRSNUIkZNVx3bKtzm7l8F3gdXOAO_ylnJgR81AuTbrWDBTAuhgzMNpXXk38sfmQq6STBdwjk6Gv?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/P8jg5m-WxBU6R7vUJFKOz7Q8EeVoigmak2xy0F29GlGa--s-65g9zo2LTeuATUs5aFkPv4UOPktjd-hYRJFRpQzSkcNQoGD-RjnZWTXYg9DlgYsBRAAGa2mGlsHHz1pKPg5iiQSUznnQJ3buTsgQNFioWEr9FPjgbaeW14kl04TmU088dmzKLo3HloLFYKCO?purpose=fullsize
 
4

Fossil Fuels

Fossil fuels formed from the remains of ancient organisms that underwent geological processes over millions of years.

The three major fossil fuels are:

  • coal
  • oil
  • natural gas

They contain energy in chemical stores.

When fossil fuels undergo combustion, chemical reactions transfer this energy into thermal energy.

A simplified energy pathway is:

chemical energy → thermal energy → mechanical energy → electrical energy


Combustion

Combustion is a chemical reaction in which a fuel reacts with oxygen and releases energy.

For a hydrocarbon undergoing complete combustion:

hydrocarbon + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water

Energy is transferred to the surroundings, mainly through heating.

For example, methane undergoes complete combustion:

CH₄ + 2O₂ → CO₂ + 2H₂O

Natural gas consists mainly of methane.


Fossil-Fuel Power Stations

A traditional thermal power station converts energy through several stages.

The general sequence is:

chemical store in fuel

↓

thermal energy of combustion products

↓

thermal/internal energy of water and steam

↓

kinetic energy of moving steam

↓

mechanical energy of turbine

↓

electrical energy from generator

At every stage, some energy is transferred into less useful forms.

https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/dThn8VexT0g6fI9KRnMpcwoTC6CMjC9H-ZdBQ_IXduCYkw5DRhNXPMFRgObtlPTAYc4vyL38F8IzYyREXLDqC1xK7LQMlrivmcjyCkphavqqRLnItryCLFTASP-avxsuHdoaBgOWzwBzmxlt6uFHNHdefFRnRgyj42rJg6M6sibcF1d7Iz7rqzrDwzKIPspx?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/Z7XEEOJSFTPRlyPiHtozGb_LFkH9shL9ynVadckZcxu_EKbi8Goqm4z6OI44SDtQFbnoDzG-qnX8WgEGLeWxWjN56ZjMItTkXfB5t9aUVvuhRFNU7Cpxk-zogoRI7Ik6JiPjhwyprSC9YJXacwLCtb_sQYXIFTpUHjfqMZtAcGLvrhgIbK6x7cGVdwS1--t7?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/ysEzEYK_V77TytlO2dPluOV28fyFVwMOAWpM0lisrE4gqsJVNe3jx-NUpxStxCXDTs92RDQ_l4tkU8uLh2hed7ECAOTVs9RqhhxAs8LOoiRybt0G3v4yzcrVEvB7nUgWeqHp19S6PQELH1bmNrUMTzQVXpVjwBNTuNSTjIiDa3GiTbtl0eYzIQWhSdQPbc31?purpose=fullsize
 
5

Coal-Fired Power Stations

Coal is burned in a furnace.

The released energy heats water to produce high-pressure steam.

The steam:

  • flows through turbines
  • causes the turbines to rotate
  • drives electrical generators

The steam is then cooled and condensed so the water can be reused.

Energy pathway:

chemical → thermal → kinetic → mechanical → electrical


Coal

Coal has historically been an important electricity-generation fuel.

Advantages include:

  • relatively high energy density
  • easy storage
  • established technology
  • reliable electricity generation
  • large existing reserves in some countries

However, coal also has major disadvantages.

Its combustion produces large quantities of:

  • carbon dioxide
  • particulate pollution
  • sulfur compounds
  • nitrogen oxides

Coal extraction can also cause substantial environmental damage.


Oil

Crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons.

After refining, it produces fuels including:

  • gasoline
  • diesel
  • kerosene
  • aviation fuel
  • heating oils

Oil is particularly important in transportation because liquid hydrocarbon fuels have relatively high energy density and are convenient to transport and store.

Energy pathway in an engine:

chemical → thermal → mechanical → kinetic


Natural Gas

Natural gas consists primarily of methane.

It is used for:

  • electricity generation
  • heating
  • cooking
  • industrial processes

Compared with coal, burning natural gas generally releases less carbon dioxide per unit of useful energy produced.

However, natural gas is still a fossil fuel.

Its combustion produces carbon dioxide.

Methane can also leak during:

  • extraction
  • processing
  • transportation
  • storage

Methane itself is a powerful greenhouse gas.


Gas Turbine Power Stations

Natural gas can be burned directly in a gas turbine.

Energy pathway:

chemical → thermal/kinetic → mechanical → electrical

Hot combustion gases expand through the turbine.

The turbine rotates a generator.

Gas turbines can start relatively quickly, making them useful for responding to changing electricity demand.


Combined-Cycle Power Stations

A combined-cycle gas turbine system improves efficiency by using energy that would otherwise be wasted.

First:

natural gas → gas turbine → generator

Hot exhaust gases still contain considerable thermal energy.

Instead of immediately releasing this energy, the exhaust is used to produce steam.

The steam then drives a second turbine.

So the system effectively uses the fuel twice:

gas turbine + steam turbine

This increases the fraction of the fuel's chemical energy converted into useful electrical energy.


Efficiency of Power Generation

Efficiency is:

efficiency = useful energy output / total energy input

As a percentage:

efficiency (%) = useful output / total input × 100

Suppose a power station receives:

1000 MJ

of chemical energy.

It produces:

400 MJ

of electrical energy.

Efficiency:

efficiency = 400/1000 × 100

efficiency = 40%

The remaining:

600 MJ

has been transferred into other forms, mainly thermal energy.


Why Thermal Power Stations Lose Energy

Important losses occur through:

  • hot exhaust gases
  • cooling systems
  • friction
  • electrical resistance
  • sound
  • heating of machinery

Large quantities of thermal energy may ultimately be transferred into the surrounding environment.

This is why cooling towers and cooling-water systems are common at large thermal power stations.


Nuclear Energy

Nuclear power uses energy stored within atomic nuclei.

Most commercial nuclear power stations use nuclear fission.

In nuclear fission, a heavy nucleus such as uranium-235 absorbs a neutron and splits into smaller nuclei.

This releases:

  • energy
  • additional neutrons
  • fission products

The released neutrons can cause further fission reactions.

This produces a chain reaction.

https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/ZJb2E5f-G70EwH1GNFfr6XaKepJhkPAeXHdlrigOmPkmRQCkGckwjezlZNq4_FiY2hcBlInDKRKA8FUVaqCYEhoMHx_OhmJLbD2kYbCf_-NBY2VVlYz-gOHtDsaKcokH4HjzRZKOBJgz31Ckd59gi6bcqCApoXZPV3bcD7YsZWPTjZddGvic9Emr4qXztQyF?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/ii-nWxV1wJI0QZUQO4zjGXIcXBg3OPFtOmTnctyzLcYqGKv2pjYCXzuQIbrZEsnZK3SOmydhaHOHJUYUCyB-Ar4erxyrd6XOqfKZ15grhLcnAJDx3F-unv_c-h-18QtJ_VixmpKWaSDZXMyPUgyZbqCAx5AM3oBXdwhWXZ-hVkv_tERH9ZW635StaqGDBYDa?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/1-mjUYzBJFCSF-AyE0YprNd-gutkaHt9qh0GICHoNIsadHZ4x8CN1U7agdKg1q18iX2qEsOqGV6sJflJccJ1uZeRiQ5opnZOz8u_cIiYnVj6TeqrzPYjALQ1ZyJSUTyJqtvvcJ6lUAADCKT7P4Jw2Ezx_p_kZXGCr7Zc31_vBnMtM6a5NPGmWAEJdvnE7Cy4?purpose=fullsize
 
5

Nuclear Chain Reactions

A simplified sequence is:

neutron + uranium-235 → fission products + neutrons + energy

Some of the newly released neutrons can cause additional uranium nuclei to undergo fission.

Without control, the number of reactions could increase rapidly.

In a nuclear reactor, the chain reaction is carefully controlled.


Nuclear Reactor

Important reactor components can include:

Fuel Rods

Contain nuclear fuel such as uranium.

Control Rods

Absorb neutrons.

Moving control rods changes the number of neutrons available to cause further fission.

Moderator

Slows neutrons in certain reactor designs, increasing the probability of further fission.

Coolant

Transfers thermal energy away from the reactor core.

Containment Structure

Provides physical barriers between radioactive materials and the environment.


Energy Transfers in Nuclear Power

The energy-transfer sequence is similar to a fossil-fuel power station after heat has been produced.

The important difference is the original energy source.

Nuclear:

nuclear → thermal → kinetic → mechanical → electrical

Fossil fuel:

chemical → thermal → kinetic → mechanical → electrical

Both commonly use steam turbines and generators.

The major difference is how the thermal energy is initially produced.


Nuclear Power Station

Energy released during fission increases the thermal energy of the reactor and coolant.

This energy is ultimately used to produce steam.

Steam turns a turbine.

The turbine turns a generator.

Therefore:

nuclear energy

↓

thermal energy

↓

kinetic energy of steam

↓

mechanical energy of turbine

↓

electrical energy

https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/gf7mhEEnpYwwpuaz5Awg7msi1bS8rN6KgyuwlSBfRJwp5B9H2fOrJNSoQ_TmrX7B8bGwvUfrjB2lALby5A3PBEztfULalfGvR6u2Vlup4jBhJLOt1ttMM6SVrfh1O7CfyCwwjxr2DQdnXbW_KSNjonwfB2Pj1wDfOgL3DmAkxuc1KIuCsgOAAi7MkHm8GWtC?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/s3u8V0DzAJMq9Jl51o3Tj4i7SyI9FxADPdXe3An2bZ2G0hpz5Kqw_ss47biLOuAAyixfpwnE4HwJ_yBJXh9vU-YYX4BDJOdIeXbXVE9lEpb-cmKLtSBCXnvr8T29jFffzYfjQHUPSnLIHVbZUSOAMMRA23Xz19H-Di5tG5XB75mAes1gdafcFb-Grjd4hq9y?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/IEJD0-spqsVN4RDGUuKjrQ4X23Vae3iFZxn6M6z8h5GLVBoRCDXgwUI7y-TaG7LztPrXNs615u8MpAHRZmS8oY3sXNDOO4Yisf_-CljqX31nxplqUzg9hfYC4f8aPnU37ZPQC-eecg1pcmlAyYLTaVxruM2e2_83J7H6_kjESvZmHTSb3Hc1TPuZxSErSxhG?purpose=fullsize
 
5

Nuclear Fuel Is Not a Fossil Fuel

This distinction is important.

Coal, oil, and natural gas are fossil fuels.

Uranium is a nuclear fuel.

Both are generally classified as non-renewable resources, but they release energy through completely different processes.

Fossil fuels:

chemical reactions

Nuclear fuels:

nuclear reactions


Energy Density

Energy density describes how much energy is stored per unit mass or volume.

Energy density by mass can be written as:

energy density = energy released / mass

Common units include:

MJ/kg

or:

J/kg

High energy density means that a relatively small amount of material can provide a large quantity of energy.


Comparing Fossil Fuels

Different fossil fuels have different energy densities.

Approximate chemical energy values can vary depending on fuel composition, but the general pattern is:

coal → moderate energy density

oil products → high energy density

natural gas → high energy per unit mass

Liquid fuels are particularly useful in transportation because they combine:

  • relatively high energy per kilogram
  • convenient storage
  • relatively high energy per unit volume
  • rapid refueling

Nuclear Energy Density

Nuclear fuel has an enormously greater energy density by mass than chemical fuels.

Chemical combustion involves changes in electron arrangements and chemical bonds.

Nuclear fission involves changes in atomic nuclei.

A small amount of nuclear fuel can therefore release vastly more energy than the same mass of fossil fuel.

This is one of the major engineering advantages of nuclear energy.


Why Nuclear Energy Density Matters

High energy density means that nuclear power stations require relatively small quantities of fuel compared with fossil-fuel power stations producing similar amounts of energy.

This can reduce:

  • fuel transportation
  • fuel storage requirements
  • total mass of fuel consumed

However, nuclear fuel and its waste require specialized handling because of radioactivity.


Worked Example: Energy Density

Suppose Fuel A releases:

30 MJ/kg

and Fuel B releases:

45 MJ/kg

For:

100 kg

of Fuel A:

E = 30 × 100

E = 3000 MJ

For:

100 kg

of Fuel B:

E = 45 × 100

E = 4500 MJ

Fuel B releases:

1500 MJ

more energy for the same mass.


Fossil Fuels and Reliability

One important advantage of fossil fuels is that the fuel can be stored.

Power stations can generate electricity when required, provided fuel is available.

This makes fossil-fuel generation generally dispatchable.

Power output can be controlled to respond to electricity demand.

This differs from variable renewable resources such as:

  • solar
  • wind

whose output depends on environmental conditions.


Nuclear Reliability

Nuclear power stations can operate for long periods and provide large amounts of relatively steady electricity.

They are particularly suited to continuous large-scale generation.

However, nuclear plants generally require:

  • complex infrastructure
  • highly trained operators
  • strict safety systems
  • scheduled maintenance and refueling

They also typically take longer to build than many smaller energy technologies.


Carbon Dioxide and Fossil Fuels

Combustion of fossil fuels releases carbon dioxide.

For hydrocarbon fuels:

fuel + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water

Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas.

Increasing atmospheric greenhouse-gas concentrations alters Earth's energy balance and contributes to climate change.

This is one of the most significant environmental impacts of fossil-fuel use.


Air Pollution

Fossil-fuel combustion can also release pollutants.

These can include:

  • particulate matter
  • sulfur dioxide
  • nitrogen oxides
  • carbon monoxide
  • unburned hydrocarbons

The amounts depend on:

  • fuel type
  • combustion conditions
  • pollution-control technologies

These pollutants can affect human health and ecosystems.


Sulfur Dioxide

Some fossil fuels contain sulfur compounds.

Combustion can produce:

sulfur dioxide (SO₂)

Sulfur dioxide can contribute to:

  • respiratory problems
  • acid deposition
  • damage to vegetation
  • changes in aquatic ecosystems

Power stations may use pollution-control equipment to remove much of the sulfur dioxide from exhaust gases.


Nitrogen Oxides

At high combustion temperatures, nitrogen and oxygen from the air can react.

This can produce nitrogen oxides, often written:

NOₓ

Nitrogen oxides can contribute to:

  • air pollution
  • smog
  • respiratory problems
  • acid deposition

Engineers use combustion controls and exhaust-treatment technologies to reduce these emissions.


Particulate Matter

Coal combustion can release tiny solid particles.

These are known as particulates.

Fine particles can enter the respiratory system and contribute to health problems.

Modern power stations can use:

  • filters
  • electrostatic precipitators
  • other pollution-control systems

to remove much of this material before exhaust gases are released.


Fossil-Fuel Extraction

Environmental impacts occur before fuels reach power stations.

Coal mining can cause:

  • habitat destruction
  • landscape changes
  • water pollution
  • dust
  • mine waste

Oil and gas extraction can cause:

  • habitat disturbance
  • spills
  • methane leakage
  • water contamination risks

Therefore, energy technologies should be evaluated over their entire life cycle.

https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/Mh_Fr-XU3G_bpIv2vKPst1Lh2ct9HBiszB2DdxRofOAsoc08eoc2HJAwgSKUZF2G6ZfcUALAcHrDph2ZHDo_W7gtRzQ1aUcnzjr_P8U2vt62qXnKCqW_l3JkWIa7Bh5ayoIJ01pCdPmLw6rSHGdFYxm29wb4ca1QRIzGnMYXoIXJUuuemswbARGCR6rYD2sd?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/XOEZt2Nlft6vAZaHhTnkN-DZQsVCKhAMsnZ_4az99x5f5_R15BACB6SYhqbgXq4XvF_jVOol2VB19RO2bnkZUSLzJ2Khu8Ni0zl20O9Qg-nO7A-lyzAfIxjCfqV9vkGmkkZd2zvEGWI0Ndzj9SiNq8qxRco_m7ni4EiRZiJJ4jqqzs4UDuXlEtGaiR5vi40b?purpose=fullsize
 
https://images.openai.com/static-rsc-4/xLiL0ycPH7hyEqd4ie8PNYy0eHE90_sK5gig0jy_syYFQvD1oYR-Wf2BdYrdQO7hNE-93ekWu8buw14K0XumV04_uWTijuf26b2EHrV2rn4Q6uyrx-2Xz3xz4sF1qrsLcDmjF65PrNXQiLWYtpyJINXnFTiWdeGjhfUj4xc6ntlFYqot_yo8yqE9Oko_a3Ld?purpose=fullsize
 
6

Oil Spills

Oil extraction and transportation create the possibility of spills.

Large spills can affect:

  • marine organisms
  • birds
  • coastlines
  • fisheries
  • food webs

Oil can persist in some environments for long periods.

Preventing spills and responding rapidly when they occur are important parts of petroleum engineering and environmental management.


Methane Leakage

Natural gas is primarily methane.

If methane leaks before combustion, it enters the atmosphere directly.

Methane is a strong greenhouse gas.

Therefore, evaluating natural gas requires considering both:

CO₂ from combustion

and:

methane leakage during production and transportation


Nuclear Power and Greenhouse Gases

Nuclear reactors do not burn fossil fuels during electricity generation.

Therefore, nuclear operation produces very low direct carbon dioxide emissions compared with coal or gas combustion.

However, life-cycle emissions can occur during:

  • uranium mining
  • fuel processing
  • construction
  • transportation
  • decommissioning

Nuclear energy is therefore better described as a low-carbon energy technology, rather than as having absolutely zero environmental impact.


Radioactive Waste

Nuclear fission produces radioactive materials.

Some remain hazardous for long periods.

Radioactive waste must therefore be:

  • contained
  • shielded
  • monitored
  • stored securely
  • isolated from people and ecosystems

Waste management is one of the major long-term challenges associated with nuclear power.


Types of Nuclear Waste

Radioactive wastes vary greatly.

Some materials have relatively low levels of radioactivity.

Others, particularly spent nuclear fuel and certain reactor materials, can remain highly radioactive.

Different waste categories require different:

  • containment
  • shielding
  • storage
  • disposal methods

Nuclear Accidents

Nuclear power plants contain extensive safety systems.

However, severe accidents can have significant consequences if radioactive materials are released.

Engineering safety therefore relies on multiple protective layers, including:

  • reactor control systems
  • emergency cooling
  • containment structures
  • backup power
  • monitoring systems
  • emergency procedures

The probability and potential consequences of accidents are both important when evaluating nuclear energy.


Thermal Pollution

Both fossil-fuel and nuclear thermal power stations may release large quantities of waste heat.

Cooling water returned to rivers, lakes, or oceans at higher temperatures can affect aquatic ecosystems.

This is called thermal pollution.

Higher water temperature can:

  • reduce dissolved oxygen
  • alter organism metabolism
  • affect species distributions

Cooling systems must therefore be carefully designed.


Water Use

Many thermal power stations require significant quantities of water for cooling.

Water availability can become an important limitation in:

  • dry regions
  • drought conditions
  • areas with competing water demands

Energy technology decisions therefore involve interactions between:

energy resources and water resources


Comparing Fossil and Nuclear Energy

Feature Fossil Fuels Nuclear Fission
Original energy store Chemical Nuclear
Renewable? No No
Fuel energy density High Extremely high
CO₂ during operation Significant Very low direct emissions
Air pollutants Can be significant Very low combustion pollution
Major waste issue CO₂ and pollutants Radioactive waste
Fuel required Large quantities Much smaller quantities
Dispatchable Yes Yes
Main electricity conversion Heat → turbine → generator Heat → turbine → generator

Coal Versus Natural Gas

Coal and natural gas are both fossil fuels, but their impacts differ.

Natural gas generally:

  • produces less CO₂ per unit of electricity than coal
  • produces much less particulate and sulfur pollution when burned
  • can be used in efficient combined-cycle plants

However:

  • it still produces CO₂
  • methane leakage can increase climate impacts

Therefore, "cleaner than coal" does not mean "no environmental impact."


Nuclear Versus Fossil Fuels

Nuclear power avoids most direct combustion emissions.

However, it introduces different challenges:

  • radioactive waste
  • high construction costs
  • complex safety requirements
  • decommissioning
  • accident risk
  • uranium mining impacts

This demonstrates an important principle:

Energy technologies involve trade-offs rather than simple good-versus-bad choices.


Energy Density and Transportation

Energy density is especially important in transportation.

A vehicle must carry its own energy supply.

High-energy-density fuels are useful for:

  • aircraft
  • ships
  • trucks
  • long-distance vehicles

This helps explain why petroleum fuels remain important in transportation.

A low-energy-density energy store may require much more mass or volume to provide the same usable energy.


Energy Density Is Not the Only Factor

A fuel with high energy density is not automatically the best energy source.

Engineers must also consider:

  • conversion efficiency
  • environmental impact
  • safety
  • cost
  • storage
  • transportation
  • infrastructure
  • reliability
  • waste

Nuclear fuel has extraordinarily high energy density, but this alone does not determine whether nuclear power is suitable for a particular location.


Power Station Efficiency

Consider two power stations.

Station A

Input:

1000 MJ

Electrical output:

350 MJ

Efficiency:

35%

Station B

Input:

1000 MJ

Electrical output:

600 MJ

Efficiency:

60%

Station B produces much more electricity from the same amount of input energy.

Higher efficiency can reduce:

  • fuel consumption
  • waste heat
  • some environmental impacts

Worked Example: Fuel Requirement

A power station must produce:

6000 MJ

of electrical energy.

Its efficiency is:

40%

Required chemical energy:

input = useful output / efficiency

input = 6000/0.40

input = 15,000 MJ

If the fuel releases:

30 MJ/kg

then:

mass = energy / energy density

mass = 15,000/30

mass = 500 kg

The station requires 500 kg of fuel for this simplified example.


Worked Example: Comparing Fuels

Fuel A:

energy density = 25 MJ/kg

Fuel B:

energy density = 50 MJ/kg

To provide:

10,000 MJ

from Fuel A:

mass = 10,000/25

mass = 400 kg

For Fuel B:

mass = 10,000/50

mass = 200 kg

Fuel B requires only half as much mass.


Carbon Capture and Storage

One proposed method of reducing carbon dioxide emissions from fossil-fuel power stations is carbon capture and storage (CCS).

The basic idea is:

  1. Capture CO₂ produced by a power station.
  2. Compress it.
  3. Transport it.
  4. Store it in suitable underground geological formations.

CCS could reduce atmospheric emissions from some fossil-fuel systems.

However, it:

  • requires additional equipment
  • consumes energy
  • increases costs
  • requires suitable geological storage
  • does not eliminate other impacts of fossil-fuel extraction

Cogeneration

A thermal power station normally releases large quantities of waste heat.

Cogeneration, or combined heat and power, attempts to use some of this energy.

For example:

fuel → electricity + useful building heating

Instead of releasing most thermal energy into the environment, some can be used for:

  • district heating
  • industrial processes
  • hot water

This can substantially improve the overall usefulness of the energy input.


Life-Cycle Analysis

Energy technologies should be evaluated from beginning to end.

For fossil fuels:

extraction → processing → transportation → combustion → waste/emissions

For nuclear energy:

uranium mining → fuel processing → power generation → waste storage → decommissioning

A complete comparison considers impacts at every stage.


Energy Security

Countries also consider energy security.

Energy security refers to having reliable access to sufficient energy.

Factors include:

  • domestic fuel supplies
  • imported fuels
  • fuel storage
  • transportation networks
  • geopolitical risks
  • power-station reliability

A fuel may be technically effective but create vulnerabilities if a country depends heavily on imports from a limited number of suppliers.


Choosing an Energy Technology

Engineers and governments may consider:

  • energy density
  • efficiency
  • cost
  • reliability
  • construction time
  • operating life
  • fuel availability
  • greenhouse-gas emissions
  • air pollution
  • waste
  • land requirements
  • water requirements
  • safety
  • public acceptance

No single factor provides the complete answer.


Common Mistakes

Calling Nuclear Fuel a Fossil Fuel

Uranium is a nuclear fuel, not a fossil fuel.

Both are non-renewable, but their energy comes from different processes.


Saying Power Stations Create Energy

Power stations transfer and transform energy.

Energy is conserved.


Saying Fossil Fuels Contain Thermal Energy

Before combustion, the relevant energy is stored chemically.

Combustion transfers energy into thermal stores.


Saying Nuclear Power Uses Combustion

Nuclear reactors use fission, not combustion.


Assuming Cooling Towers Produce Smoke

The visible plume from many cooling towers is mainly condensed water droplets, not combustion smoke.


Assuming Nuclear Power Produces No Waste

Nuclear power produces radioactive waste requiring careful long-term management.


Assuming Natural Gas Has No Climate Impact

Natural gas combustion produces carbon dioxide, and methane can leak before combustion.


Assuming Energy Density and Efficiency Are the Same

Energy density describes:

energy stored per unit mass or volume

Efficiency describes:

useful output / total input

They are completely different quantities.


Ignoring Life-Cycle Impacts

Environmental impacts occur during:

  • extraction
  • manufacturing
  • transportation
  • operation
  • waste management

not just during electricity generation.


Check Your Understanding

  1. Define a non-renewable energy resource.
  2. Name the three major fossil fuels.
  3. What type of energy is stored in fossil fuels?
  4. Describe the energy transformations in a coal-fired power station.
  5. What is combustion?
  6. Write the word equation for complete hydrocarbon combustion.
  7. Describe the energy transformations in a gas-turbine power station.
  8. Explain how a combined-cycle power station improves efficiency.
  9. Define nuclear fission.
  10. Explain what is meant by a nuclear chain reaction.
  11. What is the function of control rods?
  12. Describe the energy transformations in a nuclear power station.
  13. What is the main difference between the original energy source in fossil-fuel and nuclear power stations?
  14. Define energy density.
  15. Explain why energy density is important when comparing fuels.
  16. Why does nuclear fuel require much less mass than fossil fuel to provide a similar amount of energy?
  17. A power station receives 2000 MJ and produces 800 MJ of electricity. Calculate its efficiency.
  18. Calculate the dissipated energy in Question 17.
  19. A fuel has an energy density of 40 MJ/kg. Calculate the energy stored in 250 kg.
  20. How much of this fuel would be required to provide 20,000 MJ?
  21. Explain how fossil-fuel combustion contributes to climate change.
  22. Give three air pollutants that can result from fossil-fuel combustion.
  23. Explain why methane leakage is important when evaluating natural gas.
  24. Give two environmental impacts associated with coal mining.
  25. Explain why nuclear power is considered low-carbon but not impact-free.
  26. Describe the problem of radioactive waste.
  27. What is thermal pollution?
  28. Explain why life-cycle analysis provides a better comparison of energy technologies than simply examining the power station.
  29. Explain how cogeneration can improve the overall use of fuel energy.
  30. Evaluate the statement: "The energy source with the highest energy density is automatically the best energy source."

Key Terms

Non-renewable resource — Resource consumed faster than natural processes can replace it.

Fossil fuel — Fuel formed from ancient biological material over geological timescales.

Coal — Carbon-rich solid fossil fuel.

Crude oil — Liquid mixture of hydrocarbons that can be refined into different fuels.

Natural gas — Gaseous fossil fuel consisting mainly of methane.

Combustion — Chemical reaction between a fuel and oxygen that transfers energy to the surroundings.

Chemical energy store — Energy associated with chemical substances and their interactions.

Thermal power station — Power station that uses thermal energy to help generate electricity.

Turbine — Machine rotated by moving fluid such as steam or gas.

Generator — Device that converts mechanical energy into electrical energy.

Nuclear fuel — Material used to release nuclear energy in a reactor.

Nuclear fission — Splitting of a heavy atomic nucleus into smaller nuclei with the release of energy.

Chain reaction — Process in which neutrons released by fission cause additional fission reactions.

Control rod — Reactor component that absorbs neutrons and helps control the rate of fission.

Moderator — Material used in some reactors to slow neutrons.

Coolant — Fluid used to transfer thermal energy away from a reactor or other system.

Energy density — Energy available per unit mass or volume.

Efficiency — Fraction of input energy converted into useful output.

Greenhouse gas — Atmospheric gas that absorbs and emits infrared radiation and influences Earth's energy balance.

Particulate matter — Small solid or liquid particles suspended in air.

Radioactive waste — Radioactive material requiring controlled handling, storage, or disposal.

Thermal pollution — Environmental change caused by releasing unwanted thermal energy into an ecosystem.

Carbon capture and storage — Technology designed to capture carbon dioxide and store it away from the atmosphere.

Cogeneration — Production of useful heat and electricity from the same energy input.

Life-cycle analysis — Evaluation of impacts throughout extraction, construction, operation, and end-of-life stages.

Energy security — Reliable access to sufficient energy supplies.


Key Takeaways

  • Coal, oil, and natural gas are fossil fuels.
  • Uranium is a nuclear fuel, not a fossil fuel.
  • Fossil fuels store energy chemically.
  • Fossil-fuel combustion transfers chemical energy into thermal energy.
  • Traditional thermal power stations generally follow the pathway chemical → thermal → mechanical → electrical.
  • Nuclear power stations begin with nuclear rather than chemical energy.
  • Nuclear fission releases energy by splitting heavy atomic nuclei.
  • A controlled nuclear chain reaction provides thermal energy in a reactor.
  • Nuclear power generally follows the pathway nuclear → thermal → mechanical → electrical.
  • Energy density measures the energy available per unit mass or volume.
  • Oil products and natural gas have high chemical energy densities compared with many energy-storage systems.
  • Nuclear fuels have vastly greater energy density by mass than chemical fuels.
  • High energy density can reduce the quantity of fuel required.
  • Energy density and efficiency are different concepts.
  • Fossil-fuel power stations release carbon dioxide during operation.
  • Fossil fuels can also contribute to particulate, sulfur, and nitrogen-oxide pollution.
  • Methane leakage is an important environmental concern associated with natural gas.
  • Fossil-fuel extraction can damage landscapes, habitats, and water systems.
  • Nuclear electricity generation produces very low direct greenhouse-gas emissions compared with fossil-fuel combustion.
  • Nuclear power produces radioactive wastes that require careful management.
  • Thermal power stations can also affect water systems through waste heat and cooling requirements.
  • Combined-cycle power stations increase efficiency by using thermal energy that would otherwise be wasted.
  • Cogeneration can use waste heat for useful purposes.
  • Carbon capture and storage may reduce CO₂ emissions from some fossil-fuel systems but requires additional energy and infrastructure.
  • Life-cycle analysis considers impacts from extraction through final disposal or decommissioning.
  • Non-renewable technologies can provide reliable, dispatchable power, but their environmental impacts and finite fuel supplies must be considered.
  • Choosing an energy source requires balancing energy density, efficiency, reliability, cost, environmental impact, safety, and resource availability.

The central comparison is:

Fossil fuels: chemical energy → thermal energy → mechanical energy → electrical energy

Nuclear fuel: nuclear energy → thermal energy → mechanical energy → electrical energy

Both can provide large amounts of reliable energy, but they create very different environmental, safety, and waste-management challenges.